Last Updated: November 8, 2024
Winter driving can be challenging, with icy roads and poor visibility making it difficult to maintain control of your vehicle. Having the right winter tires can make a big difference in your safety and confidence. In this post, we'll share our top picks for the best winter tires 2023 based on factors such as traction, handling, tread life, noise, value, and overall performance. Whether driving in heavy snow or on icy roads, these tires will help you easily navigate the winter season. So, if you're in the market for new winter tires, read on for our recommendations.
You've likely heard the terms “all season,” “winter,” and “performance” used when shopping for tires. However, these are not just termed that a manufacturer's marketing department randomly chooses. Instead, all sizes of tires are available, and each tire is made for specific conditions. For example, winter tires are specifically designed to handle cold conditions and perform better than any other type of tire.
Best Overall Winter Tire
Bridgestone Blizzak WS90
- Cost: $113 – $269 per tire
- Load Range: SL – XL
- Load Index: 82 – 104
- Features: Winter, Touring, Performance, Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake
- Tread Depth: 11″ – 12″
- Max PSI: 44 – 50 PSI
- Weight: 17.0 Lbs – 32.0 Lbs
Best Winter Tire for SUVs
Michelin X-Ice Snow
- Cost: $112 to $490
- Load Range: SL – XL
- Load Index: 86 – 116
- Features: Winter, Touring, Performance, Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake
- Tread Depth: 10″ – 11″
- Max PSI: 50 – 51 PSI
- Weight: 16.0 Lbs – 41.0 Lbs
Best Studded Winter Tire
Nokian Hakkapeliitta 10 Studded
- Cost: $134 – $471 per tire
- Load Range: SL – XL
- Load Index: 107 – 126
- Features: Winter, Touring, Performance, Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake, Run Flat
- Tread Depth: 12″
- Max PSI: 47 – 51 PSI
- Weight: 15.0 Lbs – 37.0 Lbs
Top 5 Winter Tires
Reliable winter tires are paramount when the temperature drops and the roads become a treacherous mix of snow, ice, and slush. Equipping your vehicle with the right tire set can significantly improve handling, safety, and driving confidence during the challenging winter months. This guide evaluates and presents this season's top 5 winter tires, considering factors like traction, durability, and performance in extreme conditions.
- Best Overall: BFGoodrich T/A KO2
- Best Value: Yokohama Geolandar A/T G015
- Best SUV/Crossover: Michelin LTX A/T 2
- Adventure in Any Weather: Falken WildPeak AT3W
- Very Capable All-Terrain Tire: Toyo Open Country A/T III
Bridgestone Blizzak WS90 – Best Overall Winter Tire
- Rating: 4.8/5.0
- Price: $113 – $269
- Load Range: SL – XL
- Load Index: 82 – 104
- Tread Depth: 11″ – 12″
- Max PSI: 44 PSI – 50 PSI
- Weight: 17.0 Lbs – 32.0 Lbs
- Speed Rating: H – UP TO 130 MPH – T – UP TO 118 MPH
- Tire Aspect Ratio: 10.5 – 9.5
Last winter, I had the opportunity to test the Bridgestone Blizzak WS90 tires on my front-wheel drive Volkswagen Jetta during a trip through the snowy mountains of Washington. The journey was a testament to the tire's capabilities, as I encountered various challenging winter conditions. From the onset, the Blizzak WS90 tires impressed me with their exceptional traction on snow and ice. The updated winter tread compound and large contact area provided a reassuring grip, crucial for navigating the steep and slippery mountain roads. The assurance these tires provided was a game-changer, especially considering the unpredictable weather conditions in the region.
In my Blizzak WS90 review, one aspect that stood out was the tire's enhanced steering response and control due to the 30% increase in tread block stiffness over its predecessor, the WS80. This improvement was noticeable as I maneuvered through tight turns and over icy patches. The 15% more block edges on the WS90 also played a significant role in stopping power on ice, giving me peace of mind during sudden stops and sharp declines. With its thousands of biting edges, the multidimensional siping pattern consistently delivered outstanding grip, ensuring that my car remained stable and responsive in all conditions.
Durability was another key factor during my experience with the Bridgestone Blizzak WS90. Despite the harsh terrain and cold temperatures, the tires showed minimal signs of wear. This longevity is attributed to the optimized contact patch and enhanced tread block stiffness, which evenly distribute the vehicle's weight, reducing uneven tread wear. While the WS90 doesn't have a mileage warranty, its extra season of confident winter traction is a significant advantage. A reliable tire like the Bridgestone Blizzak WS90 performs exceptionally without quick wear and is invaluable for someone who frequently drives in winter conditions. The Blizzak WS90 is the best overall winter tire, delivering safety, reliability, and durability in some of the toughest winter driving conditions.
Pros
- The Bridgestone Blizzak WS90 is designed to provide excellent traction on snow and ice, helping you to maintain control of your vehicle in difficult winter conditions.
- The tire's directional tread pattern and special compound help improve handling on snow and ice, making it easier to steer and maneuver your vehicle.
- Bridgestone Blizzak WS90 winter tires are known for their long tread life, meaning they can last longer than other winter tires on the market.
- Customers highly acclaim Bridgestone's NanoPro MultiCell compound.
- According to manufacturer testing, the tires have better grip and braking performance than other winter tires.
- In milder climates, it performs like an all-season tire with more grip.
- There are also more aggressive tires if grip is a concern.
Cons
- Based on third-party reviews it seems like it might wear down quicker than advertised.
- Pretty stiff on uneven roads (dry, snowy and icy) which makes the car feel not fully under control.
- It is fairly expensive if purchased without Bridgestone rebate.
Michelin X-Ice Snow – Best Winter Tire for SUVs
- Rating: 4.8/5.0
- Price: $112 – $490
- Load Range: SL – XL
- Load Index: 86 – 116
- Tread Depth: 10″ – 11″
- Max PSI: 50 PSI – 51 PSI
- Weight: 16.0 Lbs – 41.0 Lbs
- Speed Rating: H – UP TO 130 MPH – T – UP TO 118 MPH
- Tire Aspect Ratio: 35 – 70
In the realm of winter tires, the Michelin X-Ice Snow stands as a very strong contender, especially for SUV owners. My in-depth research into these tires, which ultimately led me to choose the Bridgestone Blizzak WS90 for my vehicle, revealed the exceptional capabilities of the X-Ice Snow. This tire is engineered with Michelin's pioneering Evergrip technology, which incorporates a rigid polymer-based rubber compound for enhanced grip on both ice and snow. This feature, along with its full-depth sipes and wear-resistant design, ensures long-lasting winter traction, a key consideration for SUV drivers who face diverse and demanding winter conditions.
The performance of the Michelin X-Ice Snow in extreme weather is noteworthy. Its capabilities are evident, with a stopping distance up to 8.85 feet shorter on ice than other leading winter tires. Furthermore, the Flex-Ice 2.0™ tread compound maintains flexibility in extreme cold, ensuring excellent traction across various freezing temperatures. The v-shaped tread design optimizes the tread pattern for more biting edges in contact with driving surfaces, improving ice, snow, and slush traction. These features are particularly beneficial for SUVs, which require reliable performance in diverse terrains and weather conditions.
While the Michelin X-Ice Snow's performance is beyond question, its higher price point determined my decision to go with the Blizzak WS90. Like their cousins Michelin CrossClimate2 tires, the X-Ice Snow's price tag is felt more by anyone's wallet. However, the X-Ice Snow is an excellent choice for those who prioritize robust winter performance for their SUVs and are willing to invest in top-tier tires. It offers a 40,000-mile limited manufacturer's warranty, ensuring peace of mind for a significant duration. If you have been researching winter tires by now, you know that barely any tire company gives mileage warranties. This tire embodies Michelin's commitment to safety and performance, making it a top pick for SUV owners seeking reliable winter tires. Despite my choice, the Michelin X-Ice Snow is undoubtedly a superior tire, and its second-place standing in my selection was influenced solely by its price.
Pros
- The X-Ice has specially designed tread patterns and a special compound that provides superior grip on slippery surfaces.
- The tires are also designed to handle well in wet weather, with good water evacuation and hydroplaning resistance.
- The X-Ice's tread pattern and compound help reduce road noise, making for a more comfortable ride.
- Flexible and compatible with a wide range of vehicles; available in 128 sizes and known to work well with EVs.
- It doesn't compromise everyday usability under wet or milder conditions.
Cons
- Michelin X-Ice snow tires tend to be more expensive than other winter tires on the market.
- While the tire performs well on snow and ice, it may provide a different level of traction on dry roads than a summer or all-season tire.
- Priced high.
- Some users have reported that the Blizzak's traction in deep snow could have been better than it was, but only marginally.
NOKIAN HAKKAPELIITTA 10 STUDDED – Best Studded Winter Tire
- Rating: 4.6/5.0
- Price: $134 – $471
- Load Range: SL – XL
- Load Index: 86 – 104
- Tread Depth: 12″
- Max PSI: 47 PSI – 51 PSI
- Weight: 15.0 Lbs – 37.0 Lbs
- Speed Rating: T – UP TO 118 MPH
- Tire Aspect Ratio: 35 – 65
The Nokian Hakkapeliitta 10 Studded tire is a standout choice for those seeking the best-studded winter tire. This tire blends state-of-the-art studding technology with innovative design to deliver unmatched safety and grip on icy and snowy surfaces. Its unique, star-shaped studs are strategically positioned at optimal angles, ensuring superior cornering, braking, and lane-changing performance. This feature is particularly beneficial in the most treacherous winter conditions, where the tire's ability to maintain traction can differentiate between a safe and hazardous journey.
Notably, the Hakkapeliitta 10 prioritizes comfort alongside performance. The tire's maximum comfort stud design significantly reduces road noise, offering a quieter and more comfortable driving experience. This is crucial for drivers who spend long hours on the road and are seeking a tire that combines safety with a pleasant ride. Additionally, the tire is designed to be fuel-efficient, offering low rolling resistance and improved mileage. This means drivers can enjoy enhanced winter performance without the trade-off of increased fuel consumption.
Further enhancing its appeal, the Nokian Hakkapeliitta 10 is crafted with sustainability in mind. It features Eco Stud 10, eco-friendly studs that improve ice grip and minimize road wear, making it a more environmentally friendly choice. The tire's heavily siped tread pattern ensures improved stability and traction in various winter conditions, from ice and slush to deep snow. With a performance recognized in the Moottori test, winning the ice and snow category, the Nokian Hakkapeliitta 10 Studded tire stands as a top option for drivers who demand the highest winter safety and performance level.
Pros
- Dunlop Winter Maxx WM02 is part of a line of tires that has performed well in snowy and icy conditions.
- Tires perform well in the snow when already in motion.
- Affordable price point.
Cons
- Braking on icy surfaces has yet to be its strong point.
- Acceleration in deep snow can be an issue.
- It can slip if pushed hard.
Pirelli P Zero Winter – Best High Performance Winter Tire
- Rating: 4.6/5.0
- Price: $331 – $500
- Load Range: SL – XL
- Load Index: 90 – 108
- Tread Depth: 10″
- Max PSI: 50 PSI – 51 PSI
- Weight: 15.0 Lbs – 33.0 Lbs
- Speed Rating: V – UP TO 149 MPH – W – UP TO 168 MPH
- Tire Aspect Ratio: 30 – 55
The Pirelli P Zero Winter tire stands out as the best high-performance winter tire, offering a perfect blend of safety and driving pleasure during the cold months. This tire is an extension of the renowned P Zero line, known for its exceptional performance. It incorporates an asymmetrical tread design specifically engineered for tackling challenging winter conditions without compromising the high-speed stability and handling drivers expect from a performance tire. The high sipe density ensures excellent traction and braking on snow, while the advanced tread compound provides a reliable grip on wet and dry surfaces.
One of the key attributes of the Pirelli P Zero Winter is its ability to deliver high steering response and exceptional cornering capabilities. This makes it an ideal choice for high-powered sedans and coupes, where maintaining control and responsiveness is crucial, especially in adverse weather conditions. The tire sizes available, ranging from 19 to 22 inches, cater to various luxury and performance vehicles, ensuring drivers do not compromise their vehicle's performance capabilities even in winter.
Moreover, the Pirelli P Zero Winter excels in not just one aspect of winter driving; it provides a well-rounded performance across different winter scenarios. Whether it's icy roads, snow-covered highways, or wet and slushy conditions, this tire is designed to handle them all easily. The commitment to maintaining high performance and the safety features necessary for winter driving make the Pirelli P Zero Winter an outstanding choice for those seeking the best high-performance winter tires.
Pros
- Winter tires offer the best road feel and feedback.
- Extra durability means more treadwear.
- Great balance between high-performance and cold-weather grip.
- Best for high-performance vehicle owners that are not scared away by the hefty price tag
Cons
- VERY EXPENSIVE
- Customers have reported that these tires might wear down quicker than their competitors.
- Limited sizes are available and are usually used by higher-end sports cars.
General AltiMAX Arctic 12 – Best Affordable Winter Tire
- Rating: 4.6/5.0
- Price: $97 – $225
- Load Range: XL
- Load Index: 86 – 108
- Tread Depth: 12″
- Max PSI: 51 PSI
- Weight: 17.0 Lbs – 35.0 Lbs
- Speed Rating: T – UP TO 118 MPH
- Tire Aspect Ratio: 45 – 70
The General Altimax Arctic 12 Studdable tire is an exceptional choice for those seeking a blend of affordability and reliable winter performance. Priced between $97.00 and $225.00, this tire offers premier winter handling at a wallet-friendly cost, making it the best affordable winter tire option. The Altimax Arctic 12 builds upon the foundation of its predecessor, the original Altimax Arctic. It features a directional tread pattern that efficiently clears water and slush, ensuring strong traction in challenging weather conditions. This tire is especially versatile, providing excellent grip in snow and ice, even without studs. However, adding studs transforms it into an even more formidable force against harsh winter driving conditions.
The Arctic 12's silica-enhanced tread compound ensures that it grips the road effectively as temperatures drop below 45 degrees, whether the roads are dry, slushy, snowy, or icy. The tire's directional tread pattern, equipped with sweeping angled grooves and lateral notches, is designed to grab hold of ice and snow for a locked-in grip. The tire also features 3D Winter Sipes that lock together to reduce tread squirm while providing extra grip on ice and snow. Additionally, it is certified for use in severe winter weather, bearing the Three Peak Mountain Snowflake symbol, and includes Snow Traction rings for confident traction in deep snow.
Durability is another strong suit of the General Altimax Arctic 12. It is optimized for even weight distribution across the tire, helping resist uneven tread wear and ensuring reliable performance for consecutive winters. Although it doesn't come with a manufacturer mileage warranty, its purpose-built design for winter performance makes it a wise investment. For added peace of mind, the option for exclusive certificate coverage provides road hazard protection through winter's toughest conditions. The General Altimax Arctic 12 Studdable tire is a top choice for drivers seeking high-value, effective winter tires without breaking the bank.
Pros
- The best winter tires for the price.
- It is a specially formulated compound with physical characteristics that allow it to perform at its best.
- Studdable means that studs can easily be retrofitted to suit extreme winter driving conditions.
Cons
- Customers have reported more highway noise at higher speeds than the more expensive competitors.
- The ride quality is less soft than other brands.
What is a winter tire?
A winter tire is a type of tire that is specifically designed for use in cold, snowy, and icy conditions. Winter tires are made of a softer rubber compound that remains flexible at lower temperatures, which helps provide better traction on slippery surfaces. They also have a more aggressive tread pattern with larger, deeper grooves that help to clear snow and slush from the tread, and they may also have special features such as siping (tiny slits in the tread) to enhance grip on ice.
Winter tires are typically marked with a symbol of a mountain with a snowflake or the letters “M+S” (mud and snow) on the sidewall. These symbols indicate that the tire meets certain performance standards for use in winter conditions.
It is important to note that winter tires differ from all-season tires for snow, which are designed for use in a wider range of weather conditions but may provide a different level of grip and traction in extreme winter weather. Therefore, if you live in an area with cold, snowy winters, switching to winter tires is generally a good idea to ensure the safest and most comfortable driving experience.
How are winter tires different from all-season tires?
Winter tires are specifically designed for cold, snowy, and icy conditions. They are made of a softer rubber compound that remains flexible at lower temperatures, which helps provide better traction on slippery surfaces. Winter tires also have a more aggressive tread pattern with larger, deeper grooves that help to clear snow and slush from the tread, and they may also have special features such as siping (tiny slits in the tread) to enhance grip on ice.
On the other hand, all-season tires are designed to perform well in various weather conditions, including dry, wet, and some light snow. However, they are less specialized than winter tires and may provide a different level of grip and traction in extreme winter weather. In addition, all-season tires are typically made of a harder rubber compound that remains durable over a longer period. However, this can make them less flexible and less effective at providing traction in very cold weather.
Winter tires are generally the best for driving in cold, snowy, and icy conditions. In contrast, all-season tires are a good compromise for drivers who want a tire that can handle various weather conditions without changing tires every season.
Studded vs. Studless Winter Tires
Studded and stud-less tires are designed for cold, snowy, and icy conditions. Both tires have features that help improve traction in winter weather but differ in how they provide grip on the road.
Studded winter tires have metal studs embedded in the tread that protrude from the tire and make contact with the road surface. The studs can provide additional traction on icy roads by biting into the ice and helping the tire maintain grip. However, studded tires can also cause damage to the road surface, especially on asphalt roads, and they may be loud and uncomfortable to drive on. As a result, in some areas, studded tires are restricted or banned during certain times of the year.
On the other hand, Studless winter tires do not have metal studs and rely on other features to provide traction on ice. These features may include a softer rubber compound that remains flexible at lower temperatures, a more aggressive tread pattern with larger, deeper grooves and siping (tiny slits in the tread) to enhance grip on ice. As a result, studless winter tires are generally quieter and more comfortable to drive on than studded tires, and they do not cause damage to the road surface.
In general, studless winter tires are a good choice for drivers who live in areas with frequent snow and ice but want a more comfortable tire that is less damaging to the road. In addition, studded tires may be a better choice for drivers who need extra traction on very icy roads or live in particularly harsh winter conditions.
Who should purchase winter tires?
Winter tires are generally recommended for drivers living in cold, snowy, and icy conditions during the winter months. If you live in an area where the roads are frequently covered with snow and ice, or if you regularly drive in winter conditions, investing in winter tires is a good idea. If your area isn't known to get piles of snow during winter, then you might be okay with spending your hard-earned money on some good all-season tires for snow.
Winter tires are specifically designed to provide improved traction and handling on slippery surfaces, so they can help make driving in winter weather safer and more comfortable. They are made of a softer rubber compound that remains flexible at lower temperatures, which helps them maintain a grip on cold and slippery roads. They also have a more aggressive tread pattern with larger, deeper grooves that help to clear snow and slush from the tread, and they may have special features such as siping (tiny slits in the tread) to enhance grip on ice.
If you are unsure whether you should purchase winter tires, consider your driving habits, the weather conditions you typically encounter, and the level of traction and handling you need in winter. You can also consult a tire dealer or mechanic for more specific advice on whether winter tires are a good choice for your driving needs.
Things to consider when shopping for winter tires
It is difficult to say which is the “best” winter tire, as the best tire for one person may not be the best for another. The best winter tire for you will depend on your specific driving needs and preferences, the type of vehicle you drive, and the weather conditions you encounter.
Here are a few things to consider when choosing a winter tire:
- Size and fit: Ensure the tire is the correct size for your vehicle and has a good load-carrying capacity.
- Performance: Look for a tire that provides good traction and handling on slippery surfaces like ice and snow.
- Brand and model: Consider the reputation and track record of the brand and model you are considering.
- Price: Determine your budget and look for a tire that fits within it, keeping in mind that the initial cost of winter tires may be higher, but they can help improve safety and performance in winter weather.
- Personal preference: Consider your driving style and what you want in a tire. Do you prioritize traction, comfort, or durability?
Research and read reviews from other drivers to understand which winter tires are a good fit for you. You can also consult with a tire dealer or mechanic for more specific recommendations based on your driving needs and the type of vehicle you have.
How much do winter tires cost?
The cost of winter tires can vary significantly depending on several factors, including the tire size, the brand and model, and the retailer. Generally, you can expect to pay anywhere from $75 to $350 per tire for a quality winter tire.
Many different winter tire brands and models are available, ranging from budget-friendly options to premium tires with advanced features. The tire size can also affect the price, as larger tires are more expensive than smaller ones.
It is generally a good idea to shop around and compare prices from different retailers to find the best deal on winter tires. Also, consider purchasing a package of four tires, as this saves you money compared to buying tires individually. Finally, remember that the upfront cost of winter tires may be higher than other tires, but they can help improve safety and performance in winter weather, which can be well worth the investment.
The Car Data Tire Testing Methodology
We take pride in providing thorough and unbiased reviews of the latest tire models. To ensure that our ratings are accurate and consistent, we have developed a rating methodology that considers various factors and incorporates statistical analysis.
- Performance: We test tires for their performance in various driving conditions, including wet and dry roads, snow and ice, and off-road terrain. We also consider handling, braking, noise, and ride comfort factors. These tests are conducted using standardized procedures, and the results are analyzed using statistical methods to determine the mean and standard deviation.
- Durability: We assess the durability of tires based on factors such as tread life, resistance to punctures and cuts, and sidewall strength. These tests are conducted using standardized procedures or data gathered from third-party websites where real users share their experiences with the products we are reviewing. We then analyze the results using statistical methods to determine the mean and standard deviation.
- Value: We consider the price of the tire and compare it to its performance and durability to determine its overall value. We pay close attention to how long the tires last, the reported lifespan of the tires, as well as the ratio of those metrics when compared to the price.
- Customer reviews: We consider the experiences and opinions of other drivers who have used the tire. We do our best to disregard what seems to be fake reviews (good or bad) and make judgment calls based on our ability to filter bogus reviews well. We are human; therefore, mistakes can be made. The best reviews we provide are the ones where we extensively test the products and share real-life experiences with our readers.
- Expert opinions: We consult industry experts and gather their insights and opinions on the tire. An expert can even consist of a person with extensive knowledge of the use of tires and practical experience with them.
Our ratings are based on a scale of 1 to 5, with one being the lowest and five being the highest. We strive to provide detailed and comprehensive reviews that give drivers the information they need to make informed purchasing decisions. Overall, this methodology, which incorporates statistical analysis, allows us to provide accurate and reliable ratings for the tires we review on our site.
Best Winter Tires Rankings Bottom Line
Winter driving can be tricky and unsafe if driving on non-winter tires or tires with a minimum snow rating. Our top choice winter tire is Bridgestone Blizzak WS90 which we have tested extensively and can vouch for wholeheartedly. The tire handles extremely well in snow, is better than expected on ice, and has low road noise. It also comes in at a very reasonable price point.
If money is tight, you can go right with General AltiMAX Arctic 12, which might be noisier than its more expensive counterparts but gets the job done. Noise is a small price to pay when it comes to safety.
